Back to Blog

Email Forwarding: Forwarders, Aliases and Auto-replies

How to set up email forwarding: forwarders vs aliases vs catch-all, spam and SPF problems when forwarding to Gmail, auto-replies and employees who leave.

Nodesty Team4 min readEmail
The words Email Forwarding with Forward, Alias and Auto-reply on a dark Nodesty background

Email forwarding means automatically sending emails that arrive at one address on to another address. It's used to share emails sent to info@ among several employees, to connect a departing employee's address to their replacement or to read several addresses in a single mailbox. Used well, it makes your work easier; used badly, it can send emails to spam and damage your server's reputation.

This guide covers the difference between forwarding, aliases and catch-all, the problems with forwarding to outside addresses such as Gmail, auto-replies and what to do in common situations.

Forwarding, aliases and catch-all

MethodWhat it doesWhen to use it
ForwardingSends incoming email on to another addressWhen you want to read it in another mailbox
AliasGives the same mailbox a second addressWhen one person reads addresses like info@ and sales@
Catch-allCollects every email sent to non-existent addresses in one mailboxAlmost never; it fills up with spam
Shared mailboxSeveral people sign in to the same mailbox from their own appsWhen a team manages the same address together

An alias or forwarding works without trouble between addresses at the same provider as your domain. What really needs care is forwarding emails to an address at another provider, such as Gmail or Outlook.com.

How to set up forwarding

Your email provider's panel usually has a section called Forwarders or Forwarding. When you set it up:

  1. Enter the address to forward (info@example.com) and the destination address.
  2. Choose whether a copy stays in the original mailbox. If you keep a copy, emails aren't lost when something goes wrong with the forwarding, but the original mailbox fills up over time.
  3. Send a test email and check both that it reaches the destination mailbox and that it doesn't land in the spam folder.

Watch out for forwarding loops: If address A forwards to B and address B forwards back to A, emails go round forever and servers eventually reject them.

The problems with forwarding to Gmail

Forwarding emails sent to your business address to your personal Gmail account looks easy, but it has two problems:

1. SPF checks break. The forwarding server sends the email again on behalf of the original sender. Because your server isn't in the original sender's SPF record, Gmail may see a failed SPF check. The DKIM signature survives as long as the email isn't changed and in most cases lets the email pass authentication, but not every sender uses DKIM. We cover how these records work in our SPF, DKIM and DMARC guide.

2. Spam gets forwarded too. Spam sent to your address is also forwarded to Gmail. Gmail sees that spam as coming from your server and over time lowers your server's reputation; as a result, your real emails can start landing in spam too.

A better way: Instead of forwarding emails, add your business account to the email app on your phone and computer over IMAP. That way you read all your addresses in the same app, the emails stay on your own server and there are no authentication problems. We cover the setup steps in our IMAP vs POP3 and SMTP guide.

If you do need to forward, make sure incoming emails go through a spam filter before they're forwarded.

Auto-replies

An auto-reply (autoresponder) sends the sender an automatic answer while you're on leave or when you want to give people information straight away about emails sent to an address.

  • Set a start and end date. A forgotten "I'm on leave" reply keeps going out for months.
  • Keep it short and clear: Say when you'll be back and who can be reached in an emergency.
  • Don't share internal details. Auto-replies go to spammers too, so don't give away more than you need to about phone numbers and how your organization is set up.
  • Prevent repeated replies. Well-configured auto-replies answer the same sender only once within a set period.

Common situations

When an employee leaves: Change the account's password and shut off access. Forward emails sent to the address to a manager or add the address to the new employee's mailbox as an alias. Even if your customers keep writing to the old address, emails aren't lost.

Shared addresses such as info@ and support@: If one person reads them, use an alias. If several people read them, opening a shared mailbox and having everyone connect over IMAP is tidier than forwarding; everyone can see who answered which email.

Moving from an old domain to a new one: If you've changed your domain, forward emails sent to the old addresses to the new addresses for a while and let the people you're in touch with know your new address.

If forwarded emails bounce back, read the bounce message; we cover what the error codes mean in our Email bounced back guide.

Nodesty mail hosting

Nodesty mail hosting plans include email addresses on your own domain, webmail and IMAP/POP3 access. Incoming email is filtered by SpamExperts, so spam and malicious emails are stopped before they reach your inbox. By adding your business addresses to the email apps on your phone and computer over IMAP, you can read them on all your devices without any need for forwarding. We cover creating an email address on your own domain in our How to create a business email address guide.

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the difference between email forwarding and an alias?

Forwarding sends emails that arrive at one address on to another address, often one at a different provider. An alias is a second name for the same mailbox; for example, emails sent to info@ land straight in the alex@ mailbox, with no separate password or mailbox needed.

Why do emails I forward to Gmail end up in spam?

The forwarding server sends the email again on behalf of the original sender. Because the forwarding server isn't in the original sender's SPF record, the check can fail. Forwarded spam also lowers the forwarding server's reputation. If you can, add the account to your email app over IMAP instead of forwarding.

Should I use a catch-all address?

Usually not. A catch-all collects every email sent to non-existent addresses on your domain in a single mailbox. Because spammers try random addresses, that mailbox quickly fills up with spam. Only create the addresses you actually use.

Does a copy of forwarded emails stay in the original mailbox?

That depends on how you set up the forwarding. In most panels, you can choose to only forward the email or to forward it and also keep a copy in the original mailbox. If you keep copies, clean out the original mailbox now and then so it doesn't fill up.

Does an auto-reply answer every email?

Well-configured auto-replies answer the same sender only once within a set period and don't reply to emails from mailing lists or automated systems. Even so, keep the auto-reply on only for as long as you need it and set an end date.

What should I do with the emails of an employee who leaves?

Change the account's password and shut off the employee's access. Then forward emails sent to the address to a manager's or the replacement's mailbox, or add the address to their mailbox as an alias. Incoming emails keep reaching the new person without interruption, and customers aren't affected by the change.

Nodesty

About the author

Nodesty Team · Infrastructure & Support

The Nodesty team runs our servers, network and DDoS protection day to day and answers customer support requests around the clock. These guides come from that work.

Related articles

Launch your server now.

Build, scale, and conquer without limits on Nodesty's premium infrastructure.

                                                                                                                                                                                                                            
                                                                                                                                                                                                                            
                                                                                                                                                                                                                            
                                                                                                                             ············································                                                   
                                                ··································································································..........···························                                     
                                       ················..........................................................................................................................··············                             
                                  ·············.................::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::....................:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::................···········                        
                             ············................:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::............·········                     
                         ············.................:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::------------::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::----------------:::::::::::::::::::::..........········                  
                    ············......................::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::------------------------------------------------------------------------------------:::::::::::::.........········                
                ··········.............................................::::::::::::::::::-------------==========================================-----------------------------------:::::::::::........·······               
             ········..................:.....................................::::::::::--------=======+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++=========================------------------::::::::::.......·······              
           ······.........::::::::::::::::::::................................:::::::-----=====++++xxxxxx**************************xxxxxxxxx++++++++++++++===================------------::::::::.......·······             
          ·····.......:::::::::::::::::::::::::::.............................:::::----===+++xxx****%%%%&&&&&&#############&&&&&&&%%%%%*******xxxxxxxx++++++++++++++==============----------:::::::......······             
         ····......::::::::-------------:::::::::::..........................::::---===+++xx***%%%&&&####@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@####&&&&&%%%%*******xxxxxxxxx+++++++++++++===========--------::::::......·····             
        ····.....:::::::--------------------:::::::::.......................::::---===++xxx**%%&&&###@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@###&&&&%%%%%********xxxxxxxxxxx++++++++++++========------::::::.....······            
        ····.....:::::--------------------------::::::::....................::::---===++xx***%%&&&####@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@###&&&&&%%%%%**********xxxxxxxxxxxxx+++++++++=======------:::::.....·····            
        ····....::::::-------=============---------:::::::::................:::::---===+++xx***%%%&&&#####@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@#####&&&&&%%%%%%*************xxxxxxxxxxxxxx+++++++++======-----:::::....·····            
         ····....:::::-------================---------:::::::::...............:::::----===++++xxx***%%%%&&&&&&#################&&&&&&%%%%%%%*******************xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx++++++++======----:::::....·····            
         ·····....:::::--------=================---------::::::::::..............:::::::-----====+++++xxxxxx**************************xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx++++++++=====-----::::....·····            
          ·····.....:::::--------=================----------:::::::::::.................:::::::::-------=============++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx++++++++======-----::::....·····            
            ·····.....:::::::----------===========-------------::::::::::::.........................::::::::::::::::::------------------=============+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++=======-----::::.....·····            
              ······......:::::::---------------------------------:::::::::::::........................................:::::::::::::::-----------============+++++++++++++++++++++========------:::::.....·····             
                 ······........:::::::::---------------------------:::::::::::::::::...........................................:::::::::::::------------=============================--------::::::.....······              
                    ·········.........:::::::::::::::-------------::::::::::::::::::::::::.......................................::::::::::::::::--------------------------------------::::::::......·······                
                          ··········............::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::................................::::::::::::::::::::::::::-------------:::::::::::::::.........········                   
                                  ············..................:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::.........................:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::................···········                        
                                             ················.............................................................................................................·················                                 
                                                           ······················................................................................···························                                                
                                                                               ·········································································